The world’s largest democracy just mandated state-controlled spyware on 1.4 billion people’s phones. If you think “it can’t happen here,” think again.
December 1, 2025
The Order Has Been Given
In a move that would make George Orwell’s Ministry of Truth blush, the Indian government has issued a directive that should send chills down the spine of every freedom-loving citizen on this planet.
On November 28th, India’s Department of Telecommunications (DoT) issued an order—not made public, but sent privately to select companies—requiring Apple, Samsung, and all smartphone manufacturers to pre-install a government-owned “security” app called Sanchar Saathi on every phone sold in India.
But here’s the kicker: users will not be able to delete or disable it.
You read that correctly. The state is mandating permanent, irremovable surveillance software on personal devices. And they’re giving companies just 90 days to comply.
Already Own a Phone? Too Bad.
Think you’re safe because you already bought your iPhone? Think again.
The order explicitly instructs manufacturers to push the app to existing phones via software updates. This means your phone—the one already in your pocket—will receive mandatory government surveillance software whether you want it or not.
This isn’t a feature. This is a digital ankle bracelet for 1.4 billion people.
The “Lost Phone” Lie
The government’s justification? They claim it’s to help users recover lost and stolen phones.
Let’s be perfectly clear: this is a lie wrapped in concern trolling.
Every smartphone on the market already has robust find-my-phone features. Apple’s Find My iPhone. Google’s Find My Device. These work brilliantly without requiring permanent, undeletable government software with unknown capabilities and zero transparency.
What this actually ensures is that the government can track any phone, any person, at any time. No warrant. No oversight. No consent.
The WhatsApp Backdoor
But wait—it gets worse.
This mandate follows another DoT directive requiring end-to-end encrypted messaging apps like WhatsApp to link user accounts to the unique IMSI (International Mobile Subscriber Identity) number on SIM cards.
Here’s why this matters: In India, you cannot purchase a SIM card without providing government-issued identification.
Connect the dots:
- WhatsApp must link to your IMSI
- IMSI is tied to your SIM card
- SIM card is tied to your government ID
- Government can now identify any “anonymous” WhatsApp user
So much for encrypted messaging. So much for privacy. So much for the ability to speak freely without the state knowing exactly who you are.
Apple’s Impossible Choice
Apple loves to market itself as the champion of privacy. “What happens on your iPhone stays on your iPhone,” they tell us.
But here’s the uncomfortable truth: Apple will comply.
How do we know? Because they already have. In China, Apple:
- Stores iCloud data on servers owned by a company directly linked to the Chinese government
- Removed VPN apps from the App Store when ordered
- Removed foreign news apps at Beijing’s request
India isn’t just a growing market for Apple—it’s becoming a critical manufacturing hub as the company diversifies away from China. Walking away isn’t an option. Principles bend when billions of dollars are at stake.
The playbook is clear: Authoritarian governments have learned they can force Big Tech to become instruments of state surveillance simply by threatening market access.
This Is the Template
Pay attention, America. Pay attention, Europe. Pay attention, world.
What’s happening in India isn’t an anomaly—it’s a template. Governments around the globe are watching closely to see if this works. If India successfully mandates undeletable state surveillance apps with minimal international backlash, others will follow.
We’ve already seen:
- Pavel Durov arrested in France for refusing to compromise Telegram’s encryption
- Australia passing laws requiring tech companies to break encryption for law enforcement
- The UK’s Online Safety Bill threatening end-to-end encryption
- The EU’s Chat Control proposal that would scan private messages
The assault on digital privacy is global, coordinated, and accelerating.
The Fundamental Question
Here’s what we need to ask ourselves: At what point does a smartphone stop being YOUR device and become the government’s surveillance tool that you happen to carry?
When the state can:
- Install software you cannot remove
- Track your location at will
- Identify your “encrypted” communications
- Access your device through forced software updates
…you don’t own a phone. You carry a government tracking device that also makes calls.
What Can Be Done?
For those in India facing this reality, options are limited but not zero:
- Delay software updates as long as possible
- Use secondary devices for sensitive communications
- Explore privacy-focused alternatives that may operate outside government control
- Support organizations fighting these mandates
For the rest of us:
- Make noise. International pressure matters.
- Support digital rights organizations like the Electronic Frontier Foundation, Access Now, and the Internet Freedom Foundation (India)
- Demand your representatives take a stand against similar proposals in your country
- Vote with your wallet and voice—let companies know privacy matters to customers
The Storm Is Here
We named this site ImpendingStorm for a reason. We’ve been warning about the convergence of technology and authoritarianism for years.
This isn’t impending anymore. The storm has made landfall.
India—the world’s largest democracy, home to 1.4 billion people—has just mandated permanent government surveillance software on every smartphone. And the tech giants we trusted to protect us? They’re going to help install it.
If this doesn’t wake you up, I don’t know what will.
Stay vigilant. Stay informed. Stay free.
The price of liberty is eternal vigilance—and that’s never been more true than in the digital age.
What do you think about India’s surveillance mandate? Share this article and join the conversation. Our freedom depends on citizens who refuse to remain silent.
Recent Comments